11. How to Choose the Right Criminal Defense Lawyer

When facing criminal charges, deciding on the right criminal defense lawyer can be one of the most important choices you ever make. The outcome of your case can hinge on the skill, experience, and dedication of the attorney representing you.

You deserve one of the attentive and aggressive lawyers at Combs Waterkotte on your side. No matter the severity of your charges, an attorney is your advocate in the legal system, responsible for protecting your rights, presenting your defense, and guiding you through the complexities of the criminal justice process. This chapter will help guide you through the process of choosing the right attorney, providing you with the tools and insight needed to make an informed decision.

How to Choose the Right Criminal Defense Lawyer

Before diving into the selection process, it’s good to fully understand the role of your criminal defense lawyer. After all, you not only have the constitutional right to an attorney, you also have the right to counsel of your own choosing. A good attorney will:

  • Break down the charges against you: Your lawyer will analyze the legal elements of the charges and assess the strength of the prosecution’s case.
  • Develop a defense strategy: Based on the totality of the evidence, your defense lawyer will craft a strategy aimed at achieving the best possible outcome – whether that means dismissal of charges, a favorable plea negotiation, or a successful defense at trial.
  • Represent you in court: Your attorney will represent you – from pretrial motions to trial proceedings – challenging the prosecution’s case and advocating on your behalf.

Important Qualities to Look for in a Criminal Defense Lawyer

Selecting the right criminal defense lawyer involves evaluating a number of key qualities, including:

Experience & Expertise

Criminal law is a complex field, with intricate statutes and laws, and each kind of charge requires a specific skill set and knowledge. For example, an attorney with decades of experience in DUI/DWI cases may not be the best choice for a white-collar crime. Look for a lawyer who:

  • Specializes in Criminal Defense: An attorney who focuses exclusively on criminal defense will be more up-to-date on the latest legal developments, tactics, and trends in this area of law.
  • Has Experience With Your Specific Charges: If you’re facing drug possession charges, find an attorney who has successfully defended clients against similar allegations. If you’re charged with a violent crime or a gun charge, look for someone with a proven track record in that area.
  • Is Willing to Take Your Case to Trial: You need a law firm on your side that has experience trying cases, and is willing to do that in yours. Settling or caving to the prosecution isn’t always the best option.
  • Is Familiar With Local Courts and Prosecutors: A lawyer who knows the local legal landscape, including the judges and prosecutors, can offer valuable insights and potentially leverage those relationships to your advantage.

Reputation & Track Record

An attorney’s reputation within the community and with past clients can provide valuable insight into their effectiveness and professionalism. Consider:

  • Client Reviews & Testimonials: Read reviews and testimonials from past clients to gauge their satisfaction with the attorney’s services.
  • Peer Recognition & Awards: Lawyers who are recognized by their peers, through awards or professional associations, often have a strong reputation in their field.
  • Track Record of Success: While past results don’t guarantee outcomes, especially considering every case is different, an attorney with a history of successful outcomes, particularly in cases similar to yours, inspires confidence.

Communication & Accessibility

In any successful attorney-client relationship, effective communication is crucial. You need an attorney who will keep you informed, answer your questions, and be accessible when you need them. Evaluate their:

  • Clarity & Transparency: Does the attorney explain legal terms, concepts, and procedures in a way that you can understand? Do they clearly outline their strategy and what to expect?
  • Availability: Will the lawyer be available to take your calls and meet with you? Do they respond promptly to emails or messages?
  • Client-Centered Approach: A good attorney will listen to your concerns, involve you in decision-making, and respect your input.

Steps to Take in Choosing the Right Criminal Defense Lawyer

Once you’ve identified the qualities that ring true with you, follow these steps to pick the right criminal defense lawyer:

  • 1. Research & Compile a List of Potential Lawyers
    Start by researching lawyers in your area who specialize in criminal defense. You can use online directories, bar association referrals, and recommendations from friends or family members. Compile a list of potential candidates based on their experience, reputation, and specialization.
  • 2. Schedule Initial Consultations
    Setup consultations to meet with lawyers, discuss your case, and evaluate their suitability. You should be looking for a free, no-strings-attached consultation where you can discuss the specifics of your case and get expert legal advice and guidance on next steps. Prepare a list of questions to ask during the case review, like:

    • What is your experience with a case like mine?
    • What defense strategy would you recommend for my case?
    • What are the possible outcomes, and how likely is each?
    • How do you charge for your services, and what will be the estimated total cost?
  • 3. Assess Comfort & Confidence
    During the consultation, assess how comfortable you feel with the lawyer. Do they listen to your concerns and your side of the story? Do they explain things clearly? Do they inspire confidence in their ability to handle the intricacies of your case? Trust your instincts.
  • 4. Make an Informed Decision
    After meeting with several lawyers and gathering all necessary information, take the time to compare your options. Consider the attorney’s experience, reputation, communication style, and fees. Choose the lawyer who best aligns with your needs and gives you the most confidence in their ability to protect your rights and get you the best possible outcome.

Finding the right criminal defense lawyer is a crucial decision that can significantly impact your case. It could very well be the difference between freedom and jail time. By understanding the qualities to look for, the right questions to ask, and carefully evaluating your options, you can find an attorney who will provide the skilled and dedicated representation you need.


Open Video
Image

Featured Results:

Client Review, DUI Case

Play video
Image

Get In Touch:

St. Louis

Main Office

(314) 900-HELP

Get Directions

Clayton

By Appointment Only

(314) 900-HELP

Get Directions